I leave pointing out why tolerance is a virtue in a deeply entwined society with irreconcilable differences as an exercise for the reader. This leads to collective action problems which virtue-signaling helps to solve. Martin luther king, for example, had a lot of sympathy for socialism anti-capitalism, and might have had sympathy for communism if political realities hadnt forced him to strongly distance himself from communists. You compare israel and hamas, and the issue you see is that israel is too theocratic? Hamas literally, in its constitution (when not calling for the eradication of israel and the genocide of every jew on earth) demands the return of parts of spain and the balkans to muslim rulership, because land that was ever under muslim control is forever theirs Buy now Scott Russell Sanders Essay
And i dont want to argue about whether or not there is virtue in christian society. Rather, she observed that, in actual fact, christian churches often contained members of multiple tribesethnicitiesclasses working together. I think scotts over-stereotyping his circle because he thinks theyre good people, so they must hold good views. And certainly those who are losing any particular disagreement on the object level would want to look at tribalism as a meta level to move focus away from the object level. Or maybe instead of overconfidence its more like when you are riding a tiger, you have to continue, you cant jump off.
I suppose that if jim et al are right about the left singularity, i will soon become a far-right extremist for thinking that even people who disagree with the liberal line should have a right to free speech and not be summarily harassed out of polite society Scott Russell Sanders Essay Buy now
But thats a small sample so i dont really know what reds are like either. I think the in-group were looking for here is people who make reasoned arguments about things, enjoy constructing verbal-conceptual models, etc. Nor were there any emails about the murder of theo van gogh or the recent disclosures of sexual abuse in rotherham or a zillion other possible incidents on which there could have been emails. It seems like irenists dating is closer to what some people call courtship. This is a awesome post where you can discover so much about yourself.
If this gray tribe idea is to become a thing, it needs a different color. Its going to be difficult to give them a color code without violating the dont be an ass hole rule Buy Scott Russell Sanders Essay at a discount
I guess i became overexcited upon meeting a real time-traveler from 19th century britain. Eta if you put aside non-white and non-male, your argument gets a lot less tenable anyway. I hope youre ok with my comments too. It is common for participants in iat to feel that the order in which the blocks are presented affects the outcome. I would differentiate between multiple different meanings of outgroup, where one is a group you are not a part of and the other issomething stronger.
It usually doesnt turn out that way, though. Its also getting pretty clear that hookup culture aka free love for all has been tried and does not work. As my social circle gradually shifts left (as a result of increasing education levels) i find myself gradually becoming more like you yelling at liberals more than yelling at conservatives Buy Online Scott Russell Sanders Essay
Ive written all sorts of stuff about race and gender and politics and whatever, but that was the worst. Alas, that one was talked about for so long that the names stuck. As a bit of pure cognitive psychology, its really fascinating. It just seems like a strong word, the kind of word youd apply to your neo-nazi puppy-kicking neighbor and not the neighbor who votes red. This leads to a much poorer optimization algorithm in terms of finding a life partner, which is of course much more important to the individual and society than having lots of casual sex.
Would it be fair to say that your partly-formed attempt to spin off a grey tribe is getting a boost from the aggressive sj wing of the blue tribe? Scott, why are you making me question my values? Its uncomfortable Buy Scott Russell Sanders Essay Online at a discount
I agree, and i didnt mean to imply that homeschooling is categorically bad (i plan to homeschool, so i certainly dont oppose it). However, i dont think it detracts from his main point. What makes an unexpected in-group? The answer with germans and japanese is obvious a strategic alliance. I might even say that reddit looks more like the grey tribe than the non-grey blue tribe. Of course part of the salaries, military and non-military, go to businesses incorporated in the state of delaware, which ill lazily assume is blue.
I find the people i want to talk to are willing to talk about the flaws of both sides. I can think of criticisms of my own tribe. Effective altruism is dangerous to the survival of the human species and what we care about because of its short-term focus on increasing the number of human lives (lives saved per dollar being the objective function) Scott Russell Sanders Essay For Sale
And indeed, thats what your particularly cited studiy show, like all traits, that it is partly heritable. I personally think that a non-insane (read non-teaparty) version of the libertarians vs. I admire your work and feel that i owe you a response. Look at these studies, where it was actually tried and actually resulted in more minorities attending! L reminders of your past triumphs will not daunt me! Everyone will be judged on their own merits if i have anything to say about it. He frequently notes that he has a hard time writing about social justice in an even-handed way though its consistent to believe youre better at thinking about social justice than other people are, while believing youre worse at thinking about social justice than at thinking about other topics For Sale Scott Russell Sanders Essay
Sure number one in levels of sexual degeneracy! Well, i guess probably number two, after the netherlands, but theyre really small and shouldnt count. It is possible to make it hard to link from social media, such as redirecting based on referer. If you want a good primary source entry point, i liked moldbugs open letter (linking to moldbug triggers the spam filter and im too lazy to bitly, but its easily googled). You could consider the nyc blue tribe vs ca blue tribe divide as essentially sub-tribes. As would red team blocking blue team on twitter.
Compare this with 1920s germany (this was not a pleasant time, of course) when you had almost everything imaginable from monarchists, nationalists, catholic social conservatives, classical liberals, social democrats and communists Sale Scott Russell Sanders Essay